sponsorlink
  • Home
  • News
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
  • Movies
  • TV
  • Comics
  • Games
  • Geek
  • About
  • Contact

Review: ‘Star Trek’ – Chris’ Take

by Chris Ullrich, May 8 2009 // 1:15 PM

star_trek_final_posterUnless you live under a rock, on an island with no power, or don’t care, you are aware that there’s an 11th feature film out today based on Gene Roddenberry’s venerable creation Star Trek. In this reboot version, director J.J. Abrams, writers Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman and the rest of the team have managed to take a relatively tired franchise and inject it not only with new life, but with a new found sense of purpose as well. This purpose? To entertain, have fun and maybe even teach us a little something along the way. On all counts this film succeeds admirably.

One of the advertising tag lines for this new Star Trek reads “This is not your father’s Star Trek.” That pretty much sums up how this particular film fits into the established Star Trek universe. As in, it doesn’t. But that’s okay because this movie delivers and makes you almost forget the past and embrace this new, shiny reality for all its worth — lens flares and all. In short, this new, improved Star Trek works — and works well.

Not only is Star Trek entertaining, which it most certainly is, its great fun and satisfying on many levels and in ways few movies are these days. For long time fans of the Star Trek franchise such as myself (I started with the original series), we get to see our favorite, and very familiar, characters as they develop the friendships and relationships that will sustain them and help propel them into the future. The characters are introduced and evolve in familiar, yet new and unique, ways throughout the film as we are taken on a journey and spun off in new directions that offer endless story possibilities.

I was a bit concerned how they were going to get away with some of the obvious changes made to the established history of Star Trek. Fortunately, the method chosen works, even though it rests fundamentally on a somewhat tired time travel conceit. Still, even with that, which is explained just enough and in a very “Trek” way, you forgive the film its little flaws because in the end, its fast paced, action-oriented, humorous, exciting style engulf you and help you forget, and forgive, the film’s problems.

Is Star Trek a perfect film? No, of course not. With stories that turn on a plot contrivance with so many possible problems like time travel, this movie has a few holes large enough to fly a starship through. Does that matter? Not at all. The movie is going along with such pacing, energy and exuberance that you barely notice and just enjoy the ride.

quinto_pine_star_trek1

The cast is near perfect and not only evokes their celebrated namesakes but also bring new dimensions and conflicts to the table making these characters seem fresh and alive again. Of particular note is Zachary Quinto as Spock, who portrays not only the Vulcan side of Spock and plays it well, he also manages to infuse Spock with something else: humanity and compassion. This is a new, conflicted Spock with the same drive and determination to adhere to logic but with another dimension not seen previously. This Spock is also one who still fights for control against his baser human feelings. Fortunately for Quinto (who gets much more to do in this film than raise his eyebrow, speak monotone and stare) and for audiences, his Vulcan side doesn’t always win.

Karl Urban’s portrayal of Leonard “Bones” McCoy was also particularly good in this film. From his first moments on screen complaining about the dangers of space until he utters one of his signature catch-phrases “I’m a doctor not a  . . .”, Urban’s characterization of Bones is not only spot-on but among the most believable in the film. He takes the character and makes it his own but also still manages to tie McCoy to his past incarnation in the form of DeForest Kelly. It’s a great performance that practically steals the movie. He’s also the catalyst for much of the humor of the film.

Also of note is one character fans had been concerned about since the casting was announced many months ago: James T. Kirk. With only one other major motion picture to his credit, Chris Pine seemed like an unusual choice, to say the least, to play the iconic Captain Kirk. Fortunately, Pine manages to balance playing Kirk his own way while still showing us bits of the old Kirk. We get to see his character evolve from fatherless rebel to womanizing Starfleet Cadet to potentially disgraced student to the hero and Captain he is destined to be during the film’s two hours and fifteen minutes. This journey is well worth the time it takes and once you get to the end and Kirk takes the center seat where he belongs as Captain of the Enterprise, its very satisfying indeed.

The other aspect of Star Trek that seems to be missing from many films these days, even ones that are supposedly comedies, is humor. This film is funny and Abrams knows just where to bring the funny to help defuse the tension from previous scenes and to give the audience a rest before taking them to someplace even more tense and action packed. That kind of “roller coaster ride ” balancing ever increasing highs with pauses for humor and to regroup for the next, ever bigger, high really helps elevate this film above many others of late.

This is true even for blockbusters like The Dark Knight, which I feel could have used a bit more humor. This is also one of the reasons Iron Man worked so well. It was action-packed, tense and had life or death consequences, but it was also very funny. Just the thing big, action-packed summer blockbusters need.

Star Trek is not just a movie for fans of Trek. It’s really a movie for everyone. It’s a story of growing up, of facing your fears and of learning to work together to solve problems. During the course of the movie we learn that its okay to be afraid, to face that fear, overcome it with the help of your friends and that its possible to turn dire situations into triumphs — “no win scenario” and all. In a time when uncertainty and fear permeate the world, we need a movie like this to remind us what we are capable of as human beings.

Sure, Star Trek is also a big, loud, exciting popcorn movie full of great visuals, starships, Romulans, space battles, phasers, Vulcans and all the other elements that make a Star Trek movie so much fun. And really, there’s nothing wrong with being fun. Fortunately, in spite of its few flaws, Star Trek manages to be a great deal more than that.

–

Star Trek is now playing everywhere and is rated PG-13.

Spread the word: delicious twitter facebook digg

Posted in: Action · Movies · Paramount · Reboots and Remakes · Reviews · Star Trek
Tagged: Chris Pine, Chris' Take, J.J. Abrams, Karl Urban, Reviews, Sci-Fi, Star Trek
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.


Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

microphone Subscribe in iTunes
rss Subscribe via RSS


Episodes

  • The Flickcast – Episode 47: Money Never Sleeps
  • The Flickcast – Episode 46: Oscar Special
  • The Flickcast – Episode 45: Modern Warfare
  • The Flickcast – Episode 44: Get LOST
  • The Flickcast – Episode 43: Reboot This
  • The Flickcast – Episode 42: Absolute Justice
  • The Flickcast – Episode 41: What Is Best In Life?
  • More episodes ...

Recent Articles

  • Tim Burton Becomes A Member Of ‘The Addams Family’
  • The Beastie Boys and ‘Battlestar Galactica’ Collide In ‘Galactica: Sabotage’
  • SXSW Interview: Jonah Hill and John C. Reilly Talk About ‘Cyrus’
  • Amazon Releases Kindle App for the Mac
  • Jason Segel Will Star In His Own Muppet Movie
  • Check Out The Debut Of Mika’s ‘Kick-Ass’ Music Video
  • SXSW Interview: Director Gareth Edwards Talks ‘Monsters’

twitter facebook myspace Follow us

@TheFlickcast

  • Fetching ...





Tags

3D ABC Action Activision Amazing Spider-Man Apple Avatar Batman Battlestar Galactica Blackest Night Blu-Ray Box Office Brian Bendis Bruce Willis BSG Caprica Captain America Chuck Comedy Comics Community Dark Reign DC Deadpool Disney District 9 Dollhouse Drama DVD Ed Brubaker Fan Film Friday fox Games Geoff Johns Green Lantern Harry Potter Heroes Horror iPhone iPod Touch Iron Man Iron Man 2 iTunes J.J. Abrams James Cameron Joel McHale Johnny Depp Joss Whedon Kick-Ass Kristen Stewart Liam Neeson Lost Mark Millar Marvel Matt Fraction Megan Fox Microsoft Movies NBC New Moon Peter Jackson Playstation 3 PS3 Pull List Quentin Tarantino Reviews Robert Downey Jr. Robert Pattinson Ryan Reynolds Sam Raimi Sam Worthington Sci-Fi SDCC09 Smallville Sony Spider-Man Star Trek Star Wars Superman SXSW The Office Thor Tim Burton Trailers Transformers 2 TV Twilight Twitter Video Video Games Warner Bros Wii Wolverine woody harrelson X-Men Xbox 360 XBox Live Yvonne Strahovski Zombieland Zombies



Categories

  • 20th Century Fox
  • 3-D
  • ABC
  • Abrams
  • Academy Awards
  • Action
  • Activision
  • Adaptation
  • AMC
  • Animation
  • Announcements
  • Apple
  • Atari
  • Avatar Press
  • Awards
  • Battlestar Galactica
  • BBC
  • Best of 2009
  • Big Apple Comic Con
  • Biopic
  • Blu-Ray
  • Books
  • Boom! Studios
  • Box Office
  • Bravo
  • Business
  • Capcom
  • Cartoon Network
  • Casting
  • CBS
  • CBS Films
  • Celebrities
  • Classics
  • Clothing
  • Columbia Pictures
  • Comedy
  • Comic Previews
  • Comic Reviews
  • Comic-Con
  • Comics
  • Contest
  • Countdown To LOST
  • Cult Cinema
  • CW
  • Dark Castle
  • Dark Horse Comics
  • Daytime
  • DC
  • DC Entertainment
  • Deals and Dealmaking
  • Devil's Due
  • Dimension Films
  • Disney
  • Documentary
  • Drama
  • Dreamworks
  • DVD
  • DVD Reviews
  • Editorial
  • Editorial and Opinion
  • Electronic Arts
  • Events
  • Exclusive
  • Fan Films
  • Fandom
  • Fantastic Fest
  • Fantasy
  • Features
  • Film Festivals
  • Filmmaking
  • First Look Pictures
  • Flickcast Presents
  • Focus Features
  • Foreign Films
  • Fox Searchlight
  • FX
  • G.I. Joe
  • Games
  • Gear
  • Geek
  • Giveaways
  • Google
  • Hardware
  • Harry Potter
  • HBO
  • Holiday Gift Ideas
  • Horror
  • Horror Reviews
  • IDW
  • Image Comics
  • IMAX
  • Indie
  • Interviews
  • Iron Man 2
  • Jobs
  • Kids
  • Late Night
  • Legal
  • Lionsgate
  • Machinima Mondays
  • Macintosh
  • Macworld
  • Manga
  • Marketing
  • Marvel
  • Marvel Studios
  • MGM
  • Microsoft
  • Miramax
  • Mobile Apps
  • Movies
  • MTV
  • Music
  • Musicals
  • Mystery and Suspense
  • NBC
  • Networks
  • New Line
  • News
  • Nintendo
  • Novels
  • On The Radar
  • Oni Press
  • Paramount
  • PC Games
  • Photography
  • Photos
  • Pixar
  • Playstation 3
  • PlayStationNetwork
  • Podcasts
  • Posters
  • Prequels and Sequels
  • Press Releases
  • Pull List
  • Reality
  • Reboots and Remakes
  • Recommendations
  • Reviews
  • Romance
  • Rumor
  • Sci-Fi
  • Sci-Fi Channel
  • Screen Gems
  • Scripts
  • Short Films
  • Showtime
  • Site News
  • Social Networking
  • Software
  • Sony
  • Sports
  • Star Trek
  • Star Wars
  • Starz
  • Summit Entertainment
  • Sundance
  • SXSW
  • SyFy
  • Talk Shows
  • TCM
  • Tech
  • The CW
  • The Internets
  • THQ
  • Thriller
  • TNT
  • Top Cow
  • Touchstone Pictures
  • Toy Fair
  • Toys
  • Trailers
  • Transformers
  • Tribeca
  • TV
  • TV Digest
  • TV Ratings
  • TV Recaps
  • TV to Movies
  • Twilight
  • Twitter Giveaway
  • Universal Pictures
  • USA
  • Vertigo
  • Video
  • Video Friday
  • Video Games
  • Viral Marketing
  • War
  • War Movie Mondays
  • Warner Bros
  • Web
  • Weblink Wednesday
  • Weinstein Co.
  • Western Wednesdays
  • Westerns
  • Whedon
  • Wii
  • Writers
  • X10
  • XBLA
  • Xbox 360


Friends

  • Anthony Dalesandro
  • Brian Alvey
  • Chris Ullrich
  • Christina Warren
  • Dave Caolo
  • Davis Press
  • Mark Verheiden
  • Matt Raub
  • Michael Davis
  • Michael T. Rose
  • Nik Fletcher
  • Rick Marshall
  • Tony Mark
  • Victor Agreda, Jr.

Reading

  • Avatar Press
  • CHUD
  • Cinematical
  • Comic Book Resources
  • ComicMix
  • Coming Soon
  • Dark Horse Comics
  • DC Comics
  • Devil’s Due Publishing
  • Download Squad
  • Film School Rejects
  • IDW Publishing
  • io9
  • JoBlo
  • Marvel Comics
  • MTV Movies Blog
  • MTV Splashpage
  • Oni Press
  • Pop Culture Zoo
  • Rotten Tomatoes
  • Slackerwood
  • Slash Film
  • The Beat
  • The Comics Reporter
  • The Point Radio
  • The Unofficial Apple Weblog
  • Top Cow
  • Whedonesque

Watching

  • 20th century fox
  • 24
  • ABC
  • Battlestar Galactica
  • CBS
  • Dollhouse
  • Dreamworks
  • Family Guy
  • Fringe
  • NBC
  • Paramount
  • Robot Chicken
  • Sci-Fi Channel
  • Sony Pictures
  • Star Trek
  • Star Wars
  • Warner Brothers

Advertising and Sponsorship

If you have a product or service that you'd like to advertise on The Flickcast website or podcast. Or, want to sponsor one or more episodes of the show, please contact us via the info below.


Contact Us

Got questions, comments, suggestions or just need attention?
info [at] theflickcast [dot] com

Got tips on upcoming events, casting news or other tidbits you're dying to share?
tips [at] theflickcast [dot] com

Got a gadget, game, movie, comic or tv show you want us to review?
pr [at] theflickcast [dot] com



Copyright © 2010 The Flickcast and 1222 Studios, LLC. All rights reserved.
Design by Robert Palmer Powered by WordPress Hosted at Media Temple

Who We Are

The Flickcast is about movies, tv, comics, games and all things geek. From Star Wars to BSG to Star Trek, Citizen Kane, The Dark Knight, X-Men, Avengers, Green Lantern, Call of Duty, Assassin's Creed, Apple, the iPhone, gadgets and more, The Flickcast team will discuss, debate, entertain and enlighten with critical and insightful commentary on entertainment and geekery of the past, present and future. Find out More.